A Brief-ish History of METI, Part III: The Legacy of Frank Drake & Carl Sagan
Welcome back to our continuing series on the Brief-ish History of METI, where we examine the rise, development, and far-reaching implications of Messaging Extraterrestrial Intelligence (METI). In our first installment, we explored the foundational principles of METI, how it emerged as a possible answer to the "SETI Paradox," and the earliest pioneering experiments. In our second, we examined the groundbreaking work of Cornell Professor Frank Drake — widely regarded as the "father of SETI" — and how his relentless curiosity led to the first true experiment in the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI): Project Ozma and the legendary Arecibo Message.
We also touched on how those early efforts kindled a remarkable lifelong collaboration with fellow Cornell Professor and beloved science communicator Carl Sagan. Today, we explore how this partnership captured the imagination of NASA and ultimately produced the most ambitious physical messages ever sent into space — artifacts that may one day be discovered by an extraterrestrial civilization (ETC). These are none other than the celebrated Pioneer Plaques and the iconic Voyager Golden Records, objects now drifting through the outer Solar System or already sailing in the uncharted waters of interstellar space.
Sagan and Drake: A Meeting of Extraordinary Minds
As noted in our previous installment, Carl Sagan and Frank Drake first crossed paths in 1961, a year after the landmark Project Ozma had captured the world's attention. To build on the momentum generated by that experiment, Drake organized an informal but historically significant symposium at the Green Bank Observatory in West Virginia — the very site where Ozma had been conducted. It was at this gathering that Drake unveiled what would become one of the most famous and enduring frameworks in all of science: the Drake Equation.
The equation was born out of a practical necessity. Drake needed a structured way to organize the many unknown variables that SETI researchers were wrestling with, and by codifying them into a single formula, he gave the nascent field both intellectual rigor and a compelling research agenda. The Drake Equation posits that the number of extraterrestrial civilizations in our galaxy capable of communicating with us (N) is a product of several key variables:
- R* — The annual rate of star formation in the Milky Way galaxy
- fp — The fraction of those stars that possess planetary systems
- ne — The average number of planets per system with conditions suitable for life
- fl — The fraction of those planets that actually develop life
- fi — The fraction of life-bearing planets that develop intelligent life
- fc — The fraction of intelligent civilizations that develop detectable communication technologies
- L — The average length of time such a civilization produces detectable signals
Mathematically, the equation is expressed as:
N = R* × fp × ne × fl × fi × fc × L
What makes the Drake Equation so enduring is not that it provides a definitive answer — many of its variables remain deeply uncertain even today — but that it transforms a seemingly unanswerable philosophical question into a tractable scientific problem. With the explosion of exoplanet discoveries driven by missions like NASA's Kepler and TESS space telescopes, astronomers have been able to assign increasingly reliable values to variables like fp and ne. We now know that virtually every star hosts planets, and that rocky planets in the habitable zones of their stars are remarkably common. Yet the most philosophically charged variables — fl, fi, and especially L — remain tantalizingly unknown, keeping the equation as thought-provoking today as it was in 1961.
As for Sagan and Drake's personal connection, it actually predated their Green Bank meeting. Sagan had first become aware of Drake through the young astronomer's pioneering radiometric measurements of Venus, which revealed the planet's shockingly high surface temperature — a discovery that helped seed our understanding of the runaway greenhouse effect. The two had exchanged correspondence as graduate students, and by the time they met formally at Green Bank, a deep intellectual kinship had already begun to form. After the symposium, both joined the faculty at Cornell University, where their proximity would prove extraordinarily fruitful for the future of SETI and METI alike.
The Pioneer Plaques: Humanity's First Interstellar Message
By the early 1970s, the Apollo era was drawing to a close. Apollo 17, the final crewed lunar landing mission, had carried astronauts Eugene A. Cernan, Harrison H. Schmitt, and Ronald E. Evans to the Moon in December 1972. With the Space Race effectively concluded, NASA began charting a bold new course for robotic exploration. The Pioneer program, which had dispatched nine probes to survey the Moon, Venus, Mars, and Mercury between 1958 and 1968, was redirected toward the outer Solar System — a region that had never been visited by a human-made spacecraft.
The new Pioneer missions — Pioneer 10 and Pioneer 11 — would be the first spacecraft ever designed to traverse the Main Asteroid Belt, conduct close-up studies of Jupiter and Saturn, and ultimately achieve escape velocity from the Solar System itself. This last distinction made them historically unprecedented: they would be the first human-made objects destined to travel between the stars. It was this remarkable fact that caught the attention of journalist and science correspondent Eric Burgess, who served as the Pioneer program's unofficial chronicler.
Having heard Carl Sagan lecture passionately about communicating with extraterrestrial intelligence at a conference in Crimea, Burgess approached him with a compelling idea: why not place a physical message aboard the probes? After all, if either spacecraft were ever intercepted by an alien civilization millions of years hence, would it not be a profound missed opportunity to have sent them out "blank"? Sagan was immediately enthusiastic and enlisted Frank Drake to co-design the message. NASA approved the plan and gave the duo a remarkably short deadline — just three weeks — to design something worthy of representing humanity to the cosmos.
The artistic execution was entrusted to Linda Salzman Sagan, Carl's wife at the time, with additional contributions from space artist and science journalist Jon Lomberg, a long-time creative collaborator of Sagan's. The result was a masterpiece of compressed communication: the Pioneer Plaques.
Each plaque measured approximately six by nine inches (~15.25 cm × 23 cm) and was fashioned from gold-anodized aluminum — a material chosen for its exceptional durability and resistance to corrosion in the harsh interstellar environment. The engraved pictorial message was carefully designed to be interpretable without any prior knowledge of human language or culture. Reading from top to bottom and left to right, the message conveyed the following:
- The hyperfine transition of neutral hydrogen — the most abundant element in the universe — providing a universal unit of time and length by which the other information on the plaque could be decoded
- A pulsar map pinpointing the Sun's location relative to 15 known pulsars, whose precise rotational periods serve as a kind of cosmic timestamp and galactic address
- A diagram of the Solar System showing the probe's trajectory originating from the third planet — Earth
- A silhouette of the Pioneer spacecraft itself, providing scale for the human figures
- Figures of a naked man and woman, with the man raising his right hand in a gesture of greeting — a decision that itself sparked considerable public debate about representation
The use of hydrogen's hyperfine transition as a Rosetta Stone was particularly ingenious. The 21-centimeter wavelength associated with this transition is well-known throughout the universe and had already been proposed as the ideal frequency for interstellar communication. By encoding the plaque's units of measurement in terms of this universal constant, Drake and Sagan ensured that any technologically advanced civilization would, in principle, have the tools to decode the message.
Pioneer 10 launched on March 2nd, 1972, and Pioneer 11 followed on April 5th, 1973, both carrying their golden messages into the unknown. The Pioneer Plaques thus became humanity's first physical, interstellar greeting cards — a distinction they hold to this day. But even as the probes receded into the darkness, Sagan and Drake were already thinking about how to send something far more expressive: not just an address, but a portrait of an entire civilization.
The Voyager Golden Records: A Portrait of Humanity
The remarkable success of the Pioneer missions energized NASA and inspired an even more ambitious undertaking. In 1977, a rare and favorable alignment of the outer planets — one that occurs only once every 176 years — opened a narrow launch window for a "Grand Tour" of the outer Solar System. The twin Voyager 1 and Voyager 2 probes were designed to exploit this once-in-a-generation geometry, using each planet's gravity to slingshot themselves onward to the next in a feat of orbital mechanics known as a gravity assist, or gravitational slingshot.
The original mission plan called for detailed studies of Jupiter and Saturn, along with Saturn's magnificent ring system and its larger moons. But as the missions progressed and the spacecraft performed flawlessly, NASA extended Voyager 2's trajectory to include Uranus and Neptune — completing what became known as the legendary "Grand Tour." Together, the Voyager probes would transform our understanding of the outer Solar System, revealing the volcanic eruptions of Io, the complex braided structure of Saturn's rings, the tilted magnetic field of Uranus, and the supersonic winds of Neptune.
Like their Pioneer predecessors, both Voyager probes were on trajectories that would eventually carry them out of the Solar System entirely. Voyager project manager John R. Casani recognized this and suggested that the probes carry a "message in a bottle" for any civilization that might one day intercept them. He delegated the task to Carl Sagan, who again called upon Frank Drake and Linda Salzman Sagan, and this time also assembled a remarkable team of collaborators including astronomer Frank Drake, science writer Ann Druyan (who would later become Sagan's wife), and artist Jon Lomberg.
This time, the team chose a medium with far greater information density than a plaque: a metal phonograph record. The choice of a physical record over magnetic tape was deliberate and scientifically reasoned — magnetic storage media degrade relatively quickly in space environments due to cosmic radiation and temperature fluctuations, whereas a physical groove pressed into a durable metal disk could theoretically survive for billions of years. Working under a compressed timeline of just six weeks and with a modest budget of $1,500 (the equivalent of roughly $8,780 today, though Sagan and colleagues supplemented this with their own funds), the team produced what many consider the most profound artifact ever created by human hands.
The Voyager Golden Records are 12-inch (30.5 cm) gold-plated copper disks containing an extraordinary compendium of sounds and images representing the diversity of life and culture on Earth. NASA's Voyager Golden Record page offers a detailed breakdown of their contents, which include:
- 115 encoded images depicting human anatomy (including a silhouette of a pregnant woman), the structure of DNA, mathematical and physical concepts, geographical features of Earth, and scenes of daily human life including eating, drinking, and sports
- Greetings in 55 languages, from ancient Akkadian to modern Mandarin, reflecting the linguistic diversity of our species
- Natural sounds of Earth: wind, rain, surf, thunder, birds, whales, and other animals
- Music from across human civilization, ranging from Bach, Beethoven, and Mozart to Azerbaijani folk music, Peruvian panpipes, Senegalese percussion, and Chuck Berry's "Johnny B. Goode"
- A radioactive clock in the form of an electroplated sample of uranium-238, whose well-characterized half-life of 4.51 billion years allows any recipient to calculate how long the probe has been traveling through space
The protective outer casing of the record was itself a carefully engineered communication device. Etched with pictograms analogous to those on the Pioneer Plaques, it provided instructions for playing the record, decoding the encoded images, and locating the probe's solar system of origin. In the upper-left corner, a diagram depicts the phonograph record and stylus in the correct playing position, accompanied by binary arithmetic encoding the rotation speed (3.6 seconds per revolution), total playing duration (approximately one hour), and playback direction (outside to inside). The upper-right corner provides instructions for reconstructing the encoded images from the audio signals. The lower-left corner features the now-familiar pulsar map and the hydrogen hyperfine transition diagram — the same cosmic landmarks used on the Pioneer Plaques.
Then-President Jimmy Carter contributed a written statement that was included with the records, capturing the spirit of the enterprise with striking eloquence:
"This is a present from a small, distant world, a token of our sounds, our science, our images, our music, our thoughts and our feelings. We are attempting to survive our time so we may live into yours."
— President Jimmy Carter, 1977
Perhaps no one articulated the deeper philosophical significance of the Golden Records better than Carl Sagan himself. The act of creating the records was, in his view, as meaningful as any potential discovery of them:
"The spacecraft will be encountered, and the record played only if there are advanced spacefaring civilizations in interstellar space, but the launching of this 'bottle' into the cosmic 'ocean' says something very hopeful about life on this planet."
— Carl Sagan, 1977